In this article
- 1Start with what you actually need
- 2Questions to ask before you sign
- 3Red flags that should end the conversation
- 4What good looks like
- 5Cheap versus right
- 6How to judge it after three months
- 7Ask to see the work, not just the pitch
- 8A simple way to compare agencies
- 9What your first 90 days should look like
- 10Doing it yourself versus hiring someone
- 11What we look at first when a tradie asks for help
- 12Quick answers
- Get a free audit
Every tradie gets the same calls and emails. Someone promising page one of Google, someone offering a cheap website, someone who found you on a directory. Some are good. Plenty are not. And when you are on the tools all day, you do not have time to tell the difference, so you either sign with the first one that sounds sure of itself or you ignore the lot.
This is the checklist to run before you hand over a cent, written for plumbers, electricians, builders, HVAC and every other trade that lives on phone calls and booked jobs.
Start with what you actually need
A digital marketing agency is not one thing. Some build websites. Some run Google Ads. Some do local SEO and Google Maps. Some do all of it, and some do all of it badly. Before you talk to anyone, work out which problem you have.
- Nobody finds you when they search for your trade in your area: that is a local SEO and Google Business Profile problem.
- People find you but do not ring: that is usually a website or reviews problem.
- You want jobs this week, not in six months: that is where Google Ads comes in.
- You get enquiries but lose them, through missed calls or quotes that go quiet: that is a follow-up problem, and no amount of marketing fixes it.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Have you worked with tradies in Australia or New Zealand before, and can I talk to one? Someone who understands service areas, call-outs and emergency work will not need it explained.
- What exactly do I get each month, in plain words? If the answer is a list of buzzwords, keep looking.
- Who owns the Google Ads account, the Google Business Profile and the website? The answer should be you, every time.
- How will I know it is working? The honest measures are phone calls, booked jobs and enquiry forms, not impressions or clicks.
- What happens if I leave? Can I take my website, my accounts and my data with me?
- Is there a lock-in contract, and why?
Red flags that should end the conversation
- A guarantee of number one on Google. Nobody controls that, and anyone who promises it is either lying or about to do something Google penalises.
- Reports full of vanity numbers and no mention of calls or jobs.
- The agency owns your ad account, your Google Business Profile or your domain. If you cannot leave with them, you are renting your own business.
- A long lock-in contract with no way out if the work is poor.
- Pressure to sign today because a discount ends tonight.
- One package for every trade. A sparky chasing emergency call-outs and a landscaper chasing quotes do not need the same plan.
What good looks like
A good agency starts by looking at what you already have, tells you honestly what is worth fixing first, and explains it without jargon. It sets up call tracking so you can see which marketing produced which phone call. It reports on booked jobs. And it is fine with you owning everything.
It also does not ignore what happens after the enquiry arrives. If calls go to voicemail and quotes get no reply, more leads just means more waste. The real cost of a missed call shows how quickly that adds up.
Cheap versus right
The cheapest option is rarely the best, and the most expensive is not automatically good either. What matters is whether the work is aimed at your trade, your area and your goal, and whether someone is accountable for the result. Ask what the fee covers and what it does not, then compare like with like.
How to judge it after three months
Give it a fair run, because Google Ads can show movement quickly while local SEO takes longer. Then check three things: are more of the right people ringing, can you tell where they came from, and do you understand what you are paying for? If the answer to any of those is no, ask why in writing.
Not sure whether to start with ads or with search rankings? Google Ads vs SEO for tradies breaks down which one books more jobs and when.
Ask to see the work, not just the pitch
Anyone can describe a process. What you want to see is what they have actually done for a business like yours. Ask for examples from your trade or a close one, and ask what changed: more calls, better rankings, a cheaper cost per booked job. Names can be kept private, but the examples should be real and specific.
- Ask for a sample report and check that it shows calls and booked jobs, not just impressions.
- Ask how they track calls from ads and from Google Maps separately, so you can tell what is paying off.
- Ask to speak to a current client in a trade, even for five minutes.
- Ask what they would fix first on your own Google profile and website, and why. A vague answer means they have not looked.
A simple way to compare agencies
When you have two or three quotes, put them side by side. The cheapest is rarely the best, but the clearest almost always is.
| What to compare | A good answer sounds like | A warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| What you get | A written list of deliverables each month | Vague promises like boosting your online presence |
| Reporting | Calls, enquiries and booked jobs, shown plainly | Clicks and impressions only |
| Ownership | You own the ad account, profile, domain and website | The agency holds the accounts |
| Contract | Clear terms and a way to leave | Long lock-in with no exit |
| Trade knowledge | Understands call-outs, service areas and emergency work | Treats a plumber like a retail shop |
What your first 90 days should look like
A good agency does not disappear for three months and send a report. You should be able to see progress in stages, and each stage should make sense to you.
- Month one: look at what you already have, set up call and conversion tracking, fix the Google Business Profile and any obvious website problems.
- Month two: launch the first campaigns or pages, start the review habit, and begin to see which searches produce calls.
- Month three: cut what is not working, put more behind what is, and agree what the next quarter should aim for.
If the first month is mostly meetings and no visible setup work, ask what is actually happening.
Doing it yourself versus hiring someone
Some tradies can handle the basics themselves, especially the Google Business Profile and asking for reviews. Ads and website work are where people most often lose money or time. A fair middle path is to fix the free basics yourself, then hire help for the parts that are easy to get wrong.
What we look at first when a tradie asks for help
Before we suggest anything, we look at what is already there. It is the same short list every time, and you can use it to judge anyone, including us.
- Is the Google Business Profile claimed, complete and set to the right main category?
- Are calls tracked, so we can tell which marketing produced which phone call?
- Does the phone actually get answered, and what happens to the calls that are missed?
- Does the website load quickly on a phone and make calling easy?
The answers decide what to fix first. Often it is the free basics, not an ad budget.
Quick answers
Should I fix how I answer calls before paying for marketing?
Do it first or at the same time. More enquiries only help if they get answered, and a missed call text back is a cheap way to stop paid-for leads going to the next tradie.
Is a long contract always a bad sign?
Not automatically, but you should always be able to see what you are getting, own your accounts, and know how to leave. If the terms are vague, ask for them in writing before you sign.
Who should own my Google Ads account?
You should. The agency gets manager access, and you keep ownership, so you can take it with you if you leave.
Get a free audit
If you want to see how we would approach your trade before you commit to anything, start with a free growth plan. We look at your Google profile, your website and your competitors, and tell you plainly what we would do. No cost, no lock-in.
Or call PosFlex on +64 29 045 74452. Reply within 1 business day.